dance of democracy

It didn’t take long for the palace coup.

It’s a long, perhaps sordid, tale, so bear with me.

The first meeting, after inauguration, of the new Fernie city council started off innocently enough. But barely two minutes into the meeting, new councillor Scott Tibballs suggested adding an item to the agenda … revisiting council committee and board appointments.

Sounds innocent enough. However, council had already passed the appointments, made by Mayor Harshan Ramadass, at the inaugural meeting.

Traditionally, here and elsewhere, the mayor makes committee and board appointments after consulting with council members and council then endorses them. Tibballs argued that since council ultimately votes on the appointments, discussion on those appointments should be made at an open public meeting, which hadn’t happened.

Even though council had previously voted on some appointments, he said those appointments were made before council had any training on their new roles, which would help them make their decisions. He suggested discussing all the appointments, individually, at that meeting and council agreed.

Pin pulled, grenade launched.

Ramadass said that when he originally made the appointments, he was following the precedent of previous councils and blamed his “overzealousness” for jumping the gun.

Council then got down to business and started making appointments, keeping some of Ramadass’ original appointments and changing others.

Then came who will sit on the Regional District of East Kootenay board, an important and prestigious appointment. Traditionally, here and in other communities, the mayor sits on the RDEK board. I’ll stress it’s tradition but not legislation. Both Rossland and Sparwood named someone other than their mayor to their respective regional boards.

Ramadass had named himself to the RDEK board.

Coun. Tracey Audia-Kelly, in voicing her interest in the role said council should consider workload, overall, and “what is good for the community,” in making these appointments.

Audia-Kelly asked whether it make sense to appoint those with the most constraints on their time, i.e. the mayor, to the busiest portfolios? She said it’s not about ‘capabilities,’ but ‘capacity.’ She said the RDEK has about 40 meeting days per year, plus a councillor will need preparation time as well.

“The mayor’s office is much more strenuous than councillors,” she said. “It requires a lot more dedication and time … I have the capacity to do the (RDEK) work … That was my thinking, trying to balance the workload in the best interests of the municipality, not us as individuals.”

She said her employment situation would allow her to take the time off work to be the regional district representative.

For his part, Ramadass said he felt the RDEK is an important part of the mayor’s responsibilities and several important issues that could affect Fernie will be going through the RDEK in the coming months and felt he could “advance those files.”

Ramadass has also made arrangements with his employer to free up time for him to spend time on city business.

Then came crunch time.

Coun. Josh Gawryluk moved that Ramadass should be the city’s representative on the RDEK. No one seconded the motion, so it died on the floor. I’m not sure why Ramadass didn’t second the motion. Maybe he felt awkward seconding a motion to appoint himself, maybe he knew he wasn’t going to get it. He could have forced a vote. He didn’t.

Coun. Kathleen Dolan then moved that Audia-Kelly be the city’s RDEK director. It was seconded by Coun. Ted Shoesmith.

Audia-Kelly, Tibballs, Dolan, Shoesmith, and Coun. Phil Iddon supported the motion with Ramadass and Gawryluk voting against.

Ramadass took the setback … graciously?

“This mayor has no other responsibility than to sit at City Hall,” he said after all the appointments were made. “… That is the dance of democracy.”

The dance of democracy will undoubtedly continue.

Born and raised in Fernie, Bill Phillips is an award-winning journalist and columnist. He was the winner of the 2009 Best Editorial award at the British Columbia/Yukon Community Newspaper Association’s Ma Murray awards, in 2007 he won the association’s Best Columnist award. In 2004, he placed third in the Canadian Community Newspaper best columnist category and, in 2003, placed second. Read more Writer’s Block here.

Leave a comment

Related Stories

#FernieReport on Instagram

Follow